In or Out: Three Ladies

We haven't ripped a celeb's dress in a while, so we figured we'd bang out 3 at once. Hit it!

Jessica Alba attends the 2009 American Museum of Natural History's Museum dance
at the American Museum of Natural History in New York City wearing Narciso Rodriguez Resort 2009.

Narciso Rodriguez Resort 2009 Collection
Model: Arlenis Sosa

It's a supercute dress and the color looks great on her. We're torn on the hose, though.

IN.

Marisa Tomei attends the Launch Party for LATISSE in Los Angeles, California.

Kai Kuhne Fall 2009 Collection
Model: Karolin Walter

Five inches taken off that hem would have gone a long way. The top of the dress looks fabulous on her but that length is the very definition of dowdy. And honestly, Marisa. Is that the best you could do with your hair?

IN.

Vanessa Williams attends the 20th Annual GLAAD Media Awards at Marriott Marquis
in New York City wearing Matthew Williamson

Matthew Williamson Spring 2009 Collection
Model: Taryn Davidson

Split decision. Lorenzo likes this look on her but Tom thinks it looks a little sloppy and yes, a little young for her. Sometimes, you just can't make a short dress out of a long dress without looking like you're wearing half a dress.

UNDECIDED.

[Photos: WireImage/Style.com]


Post a comment