Judging the Judges: Nicholai by Nicky Hilton Spring 2008 Collection

One of the top 5 crappiest Project Runway judges ever, Nicky Hilton, showed her Nicholai Spring 2008 collection recently and to our intense delight, the fashion press hated it.

To be fair, there are a handful of perfectly serviceable, inoffensive designs sprinkled throughout, but damn, when she goes off the rails, she really goes off the rails. We're pretty sure some of those outfits were made out of vinyl shower curtains. And Nicky honey? That black and white stuff is about 2 seasons too old.

(Photos: Brooke/WireImage)